Eddie Dorohoy with the Montreal Canadiens (above) and as a member of the 1950-51 Victoria Cougars (below).
By Tom Hawthorn
Special to The Globe and Mail
September 19, 2009
Of all the attributes Eddie Dorohoy brought to the rink — a scoring touch, a pugnacious disposition, a keen desire to win — the one for which he gained his reputation was a quick tongue.
This was reflected in nicknames bestowed on him by teammates, who called him The Brat and The Great Gabbo. (He was also dubbed The Pistol, about which more shortly.)
Of tough-minded coach Bert Olmstead, he once said, “If Olmstead was Santa Claus, there wouldn’t be any Christmas.”
Of a tightwad owner he said, “Coley Hall is so cheap he wouldn’t give you the sleeves off his vest.”
He was aged 19 when he broke in with the Montreal Canadiens, displaying a cockiness not appreciated by older teammates.
“When I was a rookie I didn’t have so much to say,” 33-year-old veteran Murph Chamberlain told the brash newcomer.
“When you were a rookie,” Mr. Dorohoy replied, “you weren’t as good as I am.”
When Canadiens coach Dick Irvin, Sr., chewed him out for not scoring any points, the rookie explained his predicament by saying, “I’ve been trying to score from too sharp an angle — the end of the bench.”
This not so subtle critique of the coach’s judgment led to his demotion to the minors, where he would spend the following 16 seasons, never again to enjoy a spot on an National Hockey League roster.
The passing seasons failed to moderate his barbed comments. As a coach of a sixth-place junior team in Winnipeg, he summed up his predicament by describing his lineup to a reporter: “I got a Doughnut Line, which has no centre, and a Helicopter Line, which has no wings.”
One of five children born to Mary and George Dorohoy, he learned to play shinny on Seven Persons Creek near his home at Medicine Hat, Alta. The early introduction to hockey came without formal instruction and he would display a choppy skating technique, owing more to running than gliding, throughout his career.
As a cadet, 14-year-old Eddie earned a favourable write-up in Alberta newspapers for the stentorian tones with which he shouted instructions to non-commissioned officers training at Camp Sarcee, near Calgary, in 1943.
“With a voice which would be a credit to an Exhibition barker,” the Lethbridge Herald noted, “the diminutive sergeant-major snapped his orders and about 40 cadets wheeled on a dime.”
As a junior player with the Lethbridge Native Sons, he played wing on what became the highest-scoring line in all of junior hockey in the 1947-48 season. The 5-foot-9, 155-pound forward led his league in assists.
Lethbridge defeated the Moose Jaw (Sask.) Canucks to face the Port Arthur (Ont.) Bruins for the Abbott Cup, emblematic of Western Canadian junior hockey supremacy.
Mr. Dorohoy suffered a leg injuring midway through the series, though his coach insisted he dress for Game 7, which was played at Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto as a neutral site.
“I figured the team would get a life with him out there,” Lethbridge coach Scotty Munro said after the game.
Dorohoy’s sore knee was frozen and wrapped tightly, but a bodycheck in the second period knocked him out of a close game. With Dorohoy unable to finish, the Bruins cruised to a 11-1 victory and a berth in the Memorial Cup finals.
Six months later, the 5-foot-9, 155-pound Dorohoy joined the Canadiens at age 19, becoming the second youngest player in the NHL after Fleming Mackell of Toronto.
The rookie saw only limited ice time in 16 games, recording no goals, or assists. He made his crack to the coach — some accounts have him saying he was using too short a stick to score from the end of the bench — and wound up demoted to the Dallas Texans five days before Christmas in 1948. He scored in his debut with his new team.
While visiting a wealthy Texans supporter at his home, Mr. Dorohoy spotted a holstered set of revolvers. He spun them on his trigger fingers like an Old West gunslinger. The fan interrupted his play. “He told me to be careful,” Mr. Dorohoy told hockey historian Jon C. Stott in an anecdote included in the 2008 book “Ice Warriors,”“because they were loaded.” Forever after, Mr. Dorohoy was known as Pistol.
The following season he was with the Cincinnati Mohawks. His coach, the great King Clancy, liked to tell a story, perhaps apocryphal, about a game in which his goalie was injured. Lacking a substitution on the roster, Mr. Dorohoy volunteered for the thankless task of stopping rubber. The coach winced when the fill-in netminder skated onto the ice with goalie pads strapped to the wrong leg.
Soon after, Mr. Dorohoy arrived in British Columbia, where he would spend the bulk of his playing career with the Victoria Cougars and Vancouver Canucks.
In the final game of the 1950-51 season, Mr. Dorohoy scored four points to grab the league scoring title with 29 goals and 58 assists. He helped lead the Cougars to the Pacific Coast Hockey League championship.
A player who seemed always to be on the scoresheet, whether recording points or scrapping with opponents, Mr. Dorohoy became a fan favourite on the West Coast.
In 1955, he joined older brother Walter, known as Ollie, on the roster of the Seattle Americans. The older Dorohoy spent 11 seasons as a top-scoring centreman with the New Westminster (B.C.) Royals, for whom he scored an overtime winner to clinch a league title in 1950.
Eddie Dorohoy won a divisional most-valuable-player trophy for 1958-59 while skating for the Calgary Stampeders of the old Western Hockey League., scoring 109 points in 64 games. The award came with a $100 prize.
In December, 1959, he was second in the scoring race when a heavy check by Seattle defenceman Les Hunt left him with a fracture above his right ankle. He missed a season and a half while recuperating. Many suspected his career was at an end, but he managed four more fruitful seasons.
Mr. Dorohoy skated for the Los Angeles Blades, the Knoxville (Tenn.) Knights, and the New Haven (Conn.) Blades before winding up as a playing coach with the Spokane (Wash.) Jets.
After hanging up his skates, he had success coaching junior players, most notably Juha Widing, Bill Fairbairn and Larry Brown of the Brandon (Man.) Wheat Kings, all of whom went on to NHL careers lasting longer than his own.
Mr. Dorohoy worked as an assistant coach with the Los Angeles Kings in the 1970s. He managed a golf course in his home town before returning to Victoria, where he drove taxi for many years.
The 1950-51 Cougars have been inducted into the Greater Victoria Sports Hall of Fame.
During his time with Vancouver in the early 1960s, the forward was sometimes a healthy scratch from the lineup. On one such occasion, teammate Barrie Ross, sitting at the end of the bench because of an injury, remembers hearing from the stands a lone, leather-lunged voice yelling, “We want Dor! O! Hoy! We want Dor! O! Hoy!” Soon, the entire Forum crowd joined in the cry. When Mr. Ross looked over his shoulder, he saw Mr. Dorohoy in street clothes leading the chant.
Edward Eli Dorohoy was born on March 13, 1929, at Medicine Hat, Alta. He died in Victoria on June 9. He was 80. He leaves two sons, two daughters, eight grandchildren, four great-grandchildren, and a sister. He was predeceased by a granddaughter and by three brothers, including Ollie Dorohoy, who died in 1997, aged 73.